← All strategy tests
Historical simulationStocks1h barsLong onlyMixed holding periods

MA: Donchian channel breakout, 60m (profile 2) - training

Selected for a historical-results sample targeting 80% profitable, Promising tests and 20% other saved results. Individual verdicts are unchanged. This selection is not independent validation. Simulated historical strategy test for MA.US using 60-minute bars from 2025-10-12 to 2026-07-12. Asset class: stocks. Indicators and functions used: DONC_LOWER, DONC_UPPER; Box 1 condition: [close > DONC_UPPER(period=30, lag_period=1)]; Box 2 condition: [close < DONC_LOWER(period=30, lag_period=1)]. Long only. Fills at the next bar's open. Opposite signal reverses the position. Starting equity: 25,000. Position size: 25 % of equity. Stop loss: 2.5 ATR. Take profit: 2 R. Trailing stop: 4 ATR. Commission per side: 0.01 %. Slippage per fill: 0.01 points. Maximum holding period: 60 bars. Risk-setting ATR period: 14. Session: 09:30 to 16:00 (exchange time). Saved results. Trades: 18; Net P&L: -910.630956; Return: -3.642524%; Win rate: 27.777778%. No saved robustness results are available for this run.

Shared by pk78 · Published 2026-10-18 · Snapshot 2026-10-18 · Report revision 3

Test your versionLoads these rules and settings. Review them before starting a new test.

What was tested

Market
MA.US
Timeframe
60-minute bars
Test window
2025-10-12 – 2026-07-12
Engine
tv-engine-3

Simulated historical results, not live trading performance. Historical results do not predict future returns. Shared sections are selected by the author; hidden sections have not been independently verified. The author controls which sections are visible. This is a saved result; market data revisions or engine updates can change a later rerun.

Result and evidence

Too few trades

Only 18 trades, which is not enough to judge the strategy. Test a longer period.

Net P&L
-910.63
Return
-3.64%
Trades
18
Win rate
27.8%
Profit factor
0.38
Maximum drawdown
-4.97%
Average trade
-50.59
Average R
-0.48R
Sharpe ratio
-1.84
Commission paid
21.45
Chance a no-edge strategy does this well
94.2%
P&L without the 2 best trades
-1,401.47

Read before trusting the numbers

  • Only 18 trades. That is too few to tell skill from luck; test a longer period or a faster timeframe.
  • 3 stop exits filled at the open because price gapped past the stop, so they closed beyond the stop price (worst -1.88R).

The luck check is a statistical estimate for this sample, not the probability of future success. Costs, sample size and testing many variants affect how much confidence a result deserves.

Equity and drawdown

Saved simulated equity across this test window. Drag the range control to inspect a period.

Full performance statistics

Compare the full run with its long and short trades.

Statistics from the saved run, for All, Long and Short trades. N/A means unavailable or not applicable.
MetricAllLongShort
Performance
Net P&L-910.63-910.63N/A
Return on starting equity-3.64%N/AN/A
Profit factor0.380.38N/A
Average trade (expectancy)-50.59-50.59N/A
Average R per trade-0.48R-0.48RN/A
Total R-8.64R-8.64RN/A
Annualized return-4.89%N/AN/A
Buy & hold return (same period)-5.63%N/AN/A
Trades
Trades18180
Win rate27.78%27.78%N/A
Average win112.31112.31N/A
Average loss-113.24-113.24N/A
Average win / average loss0.990.99N/A
Largest win272.30272.30N/A
Largest loss-242.03-242.03N/A
Most wins in a row22N/A
Most losses in a row66N/A
Average bars in trade16.3316.33N/A
Average time in trade2d 23h2d 23hN/A
Average adverse excursion (MAE)91.8491.84N/A
Average favorable excursion (MFE)85.8885.88N/A
Risk
Max drawdown-1,256.59N/AN/A
Max drawdown %-4.97%N/AN/A
Longest drawdown198d 4hN/AN/A
Sharpe ratio (daily, annualized)-1.84N/AN/A
Sortino ratio (daily, annualized)-1.55N/AN/A
Calmar ratio-0.98N/AN/A
Time in the market21.21%N/AN/A
Costs
Commission paid21.4521.45N/A
Same-bar exits assumed stop-first0N/AN/A
Luck check
Chance a no-edge strategy does this well94%N/AN/A
Net P&L without the 2 best trades-1,401.47N/AN/A

N/A means the metric is unavailable or does not apply to that side. Colors describe individual metrics, not the reliability of the strategy.

Strategy rules

Entry / long entry

[close > DONC_UPPER(period=30, lag_period=1)]

Exit / short entry

[close < DONC_LOWER(period=30, lag_period=1)]

Execution and risk settings

Direction
Long only
Signal mode
Entry and exit
Order fills
Next bar's open
Opposite signal
Reverse position
Starting equity
25,000.00
Position size
25.00 % of equity
Stop loss
2.50 ATR
Take profit
2.00 R
Trailing stop
4.00 ATR
Move stop to breakeven at R
Not set
Maximum bars in trade
60.00
Flat at session end
No
Commission per side
0.01 %
Slippage per fill
0.01 points
Session
09:30 – 16:00 (exchange time)

Simulated trades

18 trades in this snapshot. All times are UTC.

#SideEntryExitSizeEntry priceExit priceNet P&LExit reason
1.0Long2025-10-21 14:30:002025-10-27 13:40:0010.00571.8800568.0200-39.74trailing_stop
2.0Long2025-11-25 15:30:002025-12-04 16:20:0011.00546.2100545.4500-9.56trailing_stop
3.0Long2025-12-11 15:30:002025-12-12 15:35:0011.00553.5000573.4800218.54take_profit
4.0Long2025-12-22 14:30:002025-12-31 17:20:0011.00572.2400573.980017.88trailing_stop
5.0Long2026-01-06 18:30:002026-01-12 14:30:0010.00580.6500564.0200-167.44trailing_stop
6.0Long2026-01-29 18:30:002026-02-04 14:30:0011.00539.1300543.390045.67trailing_stop
7.0Long2026-03-02 18:30:002026-03-06 14:45:0011.00523.2600512.2700-122.03stop_loss
8.0Long2026-04-08 14:30:002026-04-09 13:35:0012.00508.2300498.6100-116.65stop_loss
9.0Long2026-04-15 14:30:002026-04-20 17:00:0012.00515.1600515.86007.16trailing_stop
10.0Long2026-04-28 15:30:002026-04-28 19:00:0012.00516.0000508.1000-96.03stop_loss
11.0Long2026-04-29 14:30:002026-04-30 13:30:0011.00526.3900504.4900-242.03stop_loss
12.0Long2026-05-12 15:30:002026-05-13 13:30:0012.00506.0200495.6000-126.24stop_loss
13.0Long2026-05-19 13:30:002026-05-19 17:15:0012.00507.5700499.6000-96.85stop_loss
14.0Long2026-06-17 13:30:002026-06-17 19:20:0012.00502.9400494.9600-96.96stop_loss
15.0Long2026-06-25 14:30:002026-06-25 17:05:0012.00503.4075494.0700-113.25stop_loss
16.0Long2026-06-29 14:30:002026-07-02 19:55:0011.00514.4000539.2600272.30take_profit
17.0Long2026-07-06 13:30:002026-07-06 13:35:0011.00540.7500530.8900-109.64stop_loss
18.0Long2026-07-07 14:30:002026-07-08 13:30:0011.00542.0650529.8300-135.76stop_loss